News

EU Could Rule Hyperlinking Illegal

Later today (2nd February), the Court of Justice in the European Union (CJEU) will hear arguments as to whether hyperlinking should or should not remain legal within the EU.

Sounds insane, right? Surely the very concept is absurd; hyperlinking contributes to the very idea of the internet as a “web”. However, as internet regulation becomes ever more complex – complicated by legislation such as the Digital Millennium Copyright Act (DMCA) – the act of hyperlinking has implications beyond simply directing an internet user to a different web page. A hyperlink could, conceivably, constitute copyright infringement.

The CJEU is adjudicating over the case of GS Media BV v Sanoma Media Netherlands BV, in which the applicant (GS Media) claims that hyperlinking could constitute a violation of copyright law, and that the act of hyperlinking could constitute “‘communication to the public’ within the meaning of Article 3(1) of Directive 2001/29”.

Sanity may prevail, though, if the previous case handled by the CJEU regarding hyperlinking is anything to go by. Around the same time last year, in the case of Svensson, et al v Retriever Sverige AB, the court ruled that if a webpage is made public online with no restriction – either by paywall or content posted without the consent of copyright holder – then it is entitled to be hyperlinked.

The grey area left by the Svensson case, though, is content that exists online without the consent of the copyright holder. For example, photo content that is improperly attributed, or leaked confidential information. The implications of this undefined area could extend beyond hyperlinking and into journalism and whistleblowing.

After arguments are heard later today, a ruling by the CJEU is expected later this year.

Ashley Allen

Disqus Comments Loading...

Recent Posts

Nvidia’s GeForce RTX 5090 Possible Price Revealed

According to a new report, the GeForce RTX 5090 GPU will be very expensive. It…

7 hours ago

AMD Krackan Processor with 6 Zen 5 and Zen 5c Cores for Budget AI Laptops Leaked

A new AMD processor in the form of an engineering model has been leaked in…

8 hours ago

SK Hynix Begins Production of First 321-Layer NAND Chips

SK Hynix has claimed to be the first company to mass-produce 321-layer NAND memory chips.…

8 hours ago

Trust Gaming GXT 609 Zoxa 2.0 PC Speakers

SOUNDS GREAT – Full stereo sound (12W peak power) gives your setup a booming audio…

12 hours ago

PowerA Wired Controller for Nintendo Switch

Special Edition Yoshi design Ergonomic controller shape with Nintendo Switch button layout Detachable 10ft (3m)…

12 hours ago

Logitech G Saitek PRO Flight Rudder Pedals

Fluid Motion: These flight rudder pedals are smooth and accurate that enable precise control over…

12 hours ago