Comparing The Two & Final Thoughts
Comparison
Stacking AMD and Nvidia’s software offerings up against each other reveals that they are broadly more similar than dissimilar. They both offer virtually identical game setting optimisation options that scan your system’s hardware and uses information from a database to calculate the best settings for your installed games. Both of them offer hardware level gameplay capture: something we’ve traditionally seen reserved for expensive external PVR devices such as those made by Hauppage. Of course, I think it is fair to say that Nvidia’s gameplay capture software ShadowPlay has more sophisticated options for a number of reasons. ShadowPlay allows you to record longer durations of gameplay than AMD’s Game DVR, you can record at a greater range of resolutions and aspect ratios and the software is less buggy and works with more games due to the fact the software has been out for longer and more extensively bug-fixed. Finally, AMD and Nvidia’s software both share driver updater utilities where you can automatically detect your current driver, whether there is a newer one available and then you can download and install it all from within the software (although the driver installation wizards will launch outside it).
Those three things are the main similarities the software packages share, and they are the core features of both pieces of software. After that we see some slight differences emerge between the two when looking at other additional features. AMD’s Gaming Evolved client is more Steam-Like in that it has a game store where you can browse and download free-to-play games. There’s also an additional store where you can spend Raptr reward points on things like games, in-game content, DLC, AMD hardware and sweepstakes entries. Nvidia’s GeForce Experience software doesn’t offer any form of store where you can download games or any reward system for gamers that play games through the software like Raptr does. Nvidia’s GeForce Experience also doesn’t feature any community interaction mechanisms like forums, video sharing, discussion boards and chatrooms – AMD’s Gaming Evolved app offers this. I think this is to be expected since Nvidia’s GeForce Experience is built from the ground-up as a complementary graphics card software whereas AMD’s Gaming Evolved app is complementary graphics card software built onto the existing Raptr software base which is in itself a social media platform for gamers. Of course Nvidia snags some unique features that AMD doesn’t have. Within GeForce experience Nvidia offers its GameStream technology where you can stream your PC games directly to an Nvidia Shield 1 or 2 device. AMD offers no such technology within the Gaming Evolved App and I have not heard of any plans for AMD to announce such a feature, but then again AMD has no Shield-equivalent so it is understandable. Finally, Nvidia offers nifty LED tweaking options for supported graphics cards whereas AMD cannot offer such a thing since none of its stock designs feature LEDs other than the R9 295X2.
Final Thoughts
Who is the winner of our showdown: AMD’s Gaming Evolved (Powered by Raptr) or Nvidia’s GeForce Experience? Well, I hate to be boring and sit on the fence: but I think that’s what I am going to do here. It is fair to say that both sets of software offer the same core features and do them equally as well. Aside from those core features the additional features are subjective, some people may prefer the Steam-like social media aspect of AMD’s Gaming Evolved App as well as the reward system that gives you freebies just for playing games. Or others may prefer the simplicity and hardware focus of Nvidia’s GeForce Experience. I think Nvidia’s GeForce Experience might appeal more to the gamer who is already fed up of needing an Origin, Steam and UPlay account, let alone another account for another service that just complicates your online presence. However, you also don’t have to sign up to Raptr to use AMD’s Gaming Evolved service so it is by no means a bad thing. Of course at the end of all this its worth pointing out that absolutely no-one is going to pick their graphics card based on some free software that is bundled with it. However, if you’re already seriously torn between whether to get a GTX 770 or R9 280X for example, and they both come with good game bundles, then something like this could just be the deciding factor.
Have you used AMD’s Gaming Evolved (Powered by Raptr) App? Or Nvidia’s GeForce Experience? Let us know what you think of them!
Thank you to all our partners who provided the hardware and software that made this software comparison possible.
I have used both and for old GPUs NVIDIA is much better to optimizing games. I had a GT520 (if that can even be called a GT) and I could play with mixed settings and AA enabled BF3 and it was pretty smooth. On the other hand 5770 was a Low level on BF3 for AMD App, meanwhile I could play at High No AA pretty well. But I suppose it needs more feedback from the users.
Personally I liked the simplicity of NVIDIA better.
Using dif GPU’s = the different graphic performance, has nothing to do with the programs.
And game options are the same no matter what. So saying game options were simple with one programe over another makes zero sense.
Please read more carefully. The programs are different. The cards are totally different, and Geforce Experience does a better job at automatically setting the settings compared to Raptr.
The only real beauty of the software for me is the ability to optimise game graphics settings in an instant and amazingly they both seem to get it just about spot on, it takes away all that tedious, boring hit or miss stuff that was part of setting up games in the past. The other functions, apart from auto update I couldn’t care less about let alone use but it’s there if thats what floats your boat.
If you wanna sit on the fence Ryan thats quite alright but overall I think GFE is slightly more polished.
And how so ? just being Nvidia fanboy isn’t it ?
Both are
Personally i vote for the Experience. The Gaming Evolved has a lot of problems for me, I got so mad, I don’t even open it anymore. It’s like a beta program for years.
But the Experience works fine on my other pc.
I’ve used both and Raptr is like malware, pops up all the time with ads and garbage and I’ve never had it update drivers properly, or it will say drivers not supported for this card. Nvidia Geforce Experience is beautiful and simple, keeps my drivers up to date which is a main thing, also optimizes my game video settings for optimal performance and has the awesome shadowplay that can record your gaming and the screen for that matter with zero lag and full res. Geforce Experience is definitely way better.
Raptr is like malware, no where near the best if you’ve even tried geforce experience lately.
No it isn’t. I have Raptr and have had a popup with it. Raptr also gives you points for playing that you can trade in on in game perks, hardware discount, etc. GeForce Experience is extremely lacking in its features. Everything GeForce can do, Raptr can also, plus you earn those points in Raptre.
I have tried both. Honestly, neither one really offer any true benefit. They are both all fluff.
Could I use gaming evolved with some support on a GTX 970? I am planning to upgrade my card and don’t want to lose my points.
Raptr still has a long way to go. I recently reinstalled the AMD Crimson Drivers and Raptr after putting in an older AMD card. The Raptr software is still not great, doesn’t allow for recording in unsupported games and still doesn’t allow desktop capture. The Crimson drivers also felt a little clunky and the layout could be better.
Not really. The AMD app builds points for playing that can be traded in for perks in games or discounts on hardware. GeGorce doesn’t do that.